The Diamond “Planet”
- August 25th, 2011
- By Paul Anthony Wilson
- Write comment
Credit: Swinburne Astronomy Productions
Like wildfire, the news about the diamond planet spreads across the web to the extent where the daily tabloid The Mirror decides to write about it. And why shouldn’t they? It is exciting, right? The only problem I see is that the oversimplified summary of the published result is treated as a certainty. Although this is a great theory, which causes a lot of interest around astronomy and exoplanets, it should be treated with a bit of caution before we start imagining a sparkling diamond planet about the weight of a Jupiter floating around in space. Now is the time for astronomers to debate and discuss the results. Then who knows, once the assumptions concerning the discovery have been constrained we might in a few years time know what part of this announcement was correct or not. The way the news have presented the announcement makes it seem as if this announcement is the discovery of a diamond planet, which it is not.
Feel free to comment below.
